Today 20 November 2019, Wensday - Last updated at 19 November 2019
Abonamente

News 15 October 2019, at 12:09

Moldova: Proposed reform to fight corruption understandable, but draft law could undermine judicial independence, says Venice Commission

Marime Font

 

In an interim opinion published this week, legal experts of the Council of Europe's Venice Commission appreciate efforts by the new government in Moldova to fight corruption in government with judicial reform, but the proposals must respect the Constitution in force.

Last month, Moldovan Justice Minister Olesea Stamate requested the opinion on proposed reform of the Supreme Court of Justice and the Prosecutor's Office. The reform follows the establishment of the new government and parliamentary coalition in Moldova in June this year, and a parliamentary declaration that oligarchs have been responsible for the "control" of the Prosecutor General's office and the justice system in general. Prime Minister Maia Sandu furthermore declared that her mandate is to curb the power of oligarchs. As a result, the proposed reform establishes an extra judiciary mechanism that would re-evaluate all key persons in the judiciary and the prosecutor's offices.


Part of the reform has been met with some resistance from within the judiciary. Last month, judges submitted a request to the Superior Council of Magistracy (SCM) to convoke an extraordinary assembly of judges for the revocation of the Council's judge members' mandate. On 18 September, following the judges' application against the SCM's refusal to do so, the Chisinau Court of Appeal issued a decision obliging the Superior Council to convene the extraordinary assembly, which took place on 27 September. The Assembly withdrew the mandate of the 6 judge members of the SCM.

In its joint Interim opinion with the Council of Europe's Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law, the Venice Commission understands efforts of the Moldovan authorities to build a judiciary that promotes integrity and professionalism. It notes with satisfaction the commitment expressed by the Justice Minister to follow recommendations outlined in the opinion before finalizing the draft law and to submit the revised version of the draft law to the Commission for its final opinion. The opinion acknowledges that it us up to the Moldovan authorities to decide whether the prevailing situation in the judiciary creates enough basis for subjecting all sitting Supreme Court judges to extraordinary re-evaluation, as provided by the draft law.

A major concern is that the draft law combines such a vetting process with the reform of the Supreme Court, aimed at replacing the existing Supreme Court by a new court having a different jurisdiction and fewer judges. The combination between two different purposes obstructs the justification for subjecting all sitting Supreme Court judges to extraordinary re-evaluation and for the interference with the principle of "irremovability" of judges, according to the opinion.

This justification is even more important, as such vetting may create a dangerous precedent and may lead to an expectation that there will be a vetting scheme after each change of government, which would undermine the motivation of the judiciary and reduce its independence, the experts conclude.

Several recommendations in the opinion including the following:

- the draft law needs to be compliant with the Constitution, therefore all decisions concerning the transfer, promotion and removal from office of judges should be taken by the Superior Council of Magistracy. The Superior Council should thus be entrusted with the power to take decisions based on the recommendation contained in the report of the Evaluation Committee. The decision of the Superior Council should be public and fully reasoned and should be triggered automatically by the evaluation committee's report; provision could be made for the previous evaluation of the members of the Superior Council of Magistracy;
the draft law should not provide for an appeal against the evaluation report from one board of the Evaluation Committee to the other board; instead the draft law should provide for an appeal before a judicial body against the decisions of the Superior Council of Magistracy based on such report. This judicial body should be designed outside the cohort of judges of the Supreme Court of Justice. The criteria for selection of its members and the procedure to be followed should be set out in the law;

- the evaluation criteria that should be used in the course of the extraordinary evaluation process with respect to integrity, professionalism and lifestyle of judges should be indicated clearly and exhaustively in the draft law, and they should be the same as those already in force concerning the disciplinary liability and performance evaluation of judges;

- the number of members of the Evaluation Committee with a judicial background (i.e. former judges or former constitutional court judges) should be increased so that a substantial number of the members (if not half) has judicial background;

- the reversed burden of proof on the judge in the evaluation should be removed;

- the judge who failed the integrity evaluation should not be offered any judicial office, even in lower courts but should be subjected to a disciplinary sanction proportional to the gravity of the wrongdoing. The situation is different in case of failure to pass the professional evaluation. 

Council of Europe Communications

 Urmărește știrile Timpul.md pe Telegram
loading...
Loading...
blog comments powered by Disqus

Din aceeaşi secţiune

Cele mai noi ştiri de azi

News 6 November 2019, at: 23:30

Who is behind the attempts to expropriate Giurgiulești International Free Port?

Who is behind the attempts to expropriate Giurgiulești International Free Port?

 There have been various reports about an illegal attempt to expropriate Danube Logistics Holding BV of its shareholding in Danube Logistics SRL, the operator and general investor in Giurgiulesti International Free Port. In order to discuss this subject in greater detail TIMPIL.MD had a...

( ) Read all

News 26 October 2019, ora: 09:53

The Guardian How liberalism became ‘the god that failed’ in eastern Europe

How liberalism became ‘the god that failed’ in eastern Europe

 After communism fell, the promises of western liberalism to transform central and eastern Europe were never fully realised – and now we are seeing the backlash.

( ) Read all

News 18 October 2019, at: 09:48

 Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan put US President Donald Trump's letter "in the bin", the BBC has been told.

( ) Read all

News 12 October 2019, at: 09:56

Will The OSCE ‘Democratize’ Russia’s Occupation in Ukraine’s Donbas?

Will The OSCE ‘Democratize’ Russia’s Occupation in Ukraine’s Donbas?

 Kyiv has co-signed with Russia and the Donetsk and Luhansk “people’s republics” (DPR, LPR) a commitment to: a) accept the holding of “local elections” in that Russian-controlled territory of Ukraine and b) accept the Organization for Security and Cooperation in...

( ) Read all

News 7 October 2019, at: 09:20

 On the occasion of the book launch, "Panorama of communism in Soviet Moldova", writer from the Republic of Moldova, Maria Sleahtitchi, one of the authors of the volume, spoke to B1.ro about the condition of Moldovan literature in a society strongly divided by ethnic and political...

( ) Read all

News 4 October 2019, at: 07:26

 The Council of Europe is concerned about the possible adoption by the Verkhovna Rada of a bill amending some laws of Ukraine regarding the activities of the judiciary (No. 1008), which provides, inter alia, a reduction in the number of judges of the Supreme Court and changes in the...

( ) Read all

News 1 October 2019, at: 21:51

Thomas Moser: Rafiq Aliyev is attempting to coerce me into agreeing to the sale of Danube Logistics Holding BV

Thomas Moser: Rafiq Aliyev is attempting to coerce me into agreeing to the sale of Danube Logistics Holding BV

 I would like to clarify a number of false and misleading press reports about Danube Logistics Holding BV’s acquisition of Danube Logistics SRL in 2011 and other matters that have been circulating in Moldova last week.

( ) Read all

News 1 October 2019, at: 17:06

 The United States continues to closely follow and support efforts to reform and strengthen Moldova’s justice system.

( ) Read all

News 24 September 2019, at: 15:56

I begin with an allegory expressed by prof. Vytautas Landsbergis, the first head of the restored State of Lithuania, who used to address the options for geopolitical orientation after the restoration of the independence. When asked about the possibility in 1990s for Lithuania to choose...

( ) Read all

News 23 September 2019, at: 11:47

​Romania's President, the prime minister and the leader of the second biggest opposition party will face each other in presidential elections, along with five other candidates. This weekend saw the conclusion for the period of registration of runners in the elections due to take place in...

( ) Read all

News 19 September 2019, at: 23:05

 You’ve probably already heard the Romanian language from friends, relatives or strangers in the community. Maybe you have even made an attempt to learn basic phrases of Romanian for an upcoming trip. But have you ever wondered how the language was formed? We found ourselves wondering...

( ) Read all

News 18 September 2019, ora: 10:50

COMMENT: Moldovan president’s determination to stop an airport deal appears increasingly misleading

COMMENT: Moldovan president’s determination to stop an airport deal appears increasingly misleading

Regime change in Moldova has been met with cautious optimism by Brussels, as President Igor Dodon pledged to dismantle the businesses that have long dominated political life. But mere months after a contentious coalition was brokered between Dodon and Maia Sandu, both international observers and...

( ) Read all

News 17 September 2019, ora: 13:51

The national interest: Russia Is Rapidly Procuring More Fifth-Generation Su-57s

The national interest: Russia Is Rapidly Procuring More Fifth-Generation Su-57s

 In July 2019, Russia announced a major purchase of its fifth-generation stealth air superiority fighter, the Su-57.

( ) Read all

News 9 September 2019, ora: 12:07

Moldova not recognizing so-called elections in Crimea and Sevastopol

Moldova not recognizing so-called elections in Crimea and Sevastopol

Moldova does not recognize the so-called elections that were held in Russia-annexed Crimea and Sevastopol on September 8, the press service of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration of Moldova has reported.

( ) Read all

News 8 September 2019, at: 19:29

The Washington Post: Trump tries to force Ukraine to meddle in the 2020 election

The Washington Post: Trump tries to force Ukraine to meddle in the 2020 election

 UKRAINE’S NEOPHYTE president, Volodymyr Zelensky, took a big step this week toward proving that he will be, as he promised, the most pro-reform president in Ukraine’s history. On Monday, he laid out a breathtakingly ambitious five-year plan including virtually every measure the...

( ) Read all

News 7 September 2019, ora: 19:23

Film director Oleg Sentsov among 70 released in Russia-Ukraine prisoner swap / VIDEO

Film director Oleg Sentsov among 70 released in Russia-Ukraine prisoner swap / VIDEO

 Russia and Ukraine carried out a long-awaited swap of 70 prisoners on Saturday, in a deal hailed by President Volodymyr Zelensky as a “first step” towards ending their conflict.

( ) Read all

News 1 September 2019, ora: 08:51

ECHR to consider Ukraine's ‘Crimean’ lawsuit against Russia in September

ECHR to consider Ukraine's ‘Crimean’ lawsuit against Russia in September

 In September, the European Court of Human Rights will consider an interstate case on a lawsuit filed by Ukraine against Russia on March 13, 2014, regarding the violation of human rights in the territory of the annexed Crimea.

( ) Read all

News 31 August 2019, ora: 10:20

Vladimir Putin and his minions continue to whitewash the Stalinist past (washingtonpost.com)

Vladimir Putin and his minions continue to whitewash the Stalinist past (washingtonpost.com)

This past week, the Russian Military Historical Society — a government-affiliated body headed by Vladimir Putin’s culture minister, Vladimir Medinsky — concluded its second research expedition to the Sandarmokh forest in the northwestern region of Karelia. Its purported aim was...

( ) Read all

News 29 August 2019, ora: 07:14

Soviet Symbols Aren't 'Funny,' Lithuania Tells Amazon

Soviet Symbols Aren't 'Funny,' Lithuania Tells Amazon

 Lithuania has urged American online retailer Amazon to stop selling clothing featuring the hammer and sickle and other Soviet symbols, which it says are offensive to victims of Soviet-era persecution.

( ) Read all

News 16 August 2019, ora: 08:55

PM’s Plan to Commemorate Victims of Totalitarianism Divides Moldova

PM’s Plan to Commemorate Victims of Totalitarianism Divides Moldova

 Move by pro-EU Prime Minister to turn August 23 into a day of remembrance for victims of totalitarianism may trigger an ideological fight with her pro-Russian coalition partners – who celebrate the victory in 1944 of the Soviet Red Army on that day.

( ) Read all
Current tier / breakpoint: xs sm md lg xl (= visible only on this breakpoint)

.hidden-xs-down .hidden-sm-down .hidden-md-down .hidden-lg-down

.hidden-xs-up .hidden-sm-up .hidden-md-up .hidden-lg-up .hidden-xl

.hidden-xs (only) .hidden-sm (only) .hidden-md (only) .hidden-lg (only) .hidden-xl (only)