Today 24 February 2020, Monday - Last updated at ora 20:50
Abonamente

News 21 January 2020, at 12:55

Revisiting the Ukraine- Russia- EU triangular dynamics

Marime Font

 With the narrative that floats around, one is tempted to think that the Ukraine crisis is all about Crimea; that it started and ended there. So what about the internal oblasts like Odessa, Kharkiv, Luhansk, and Donetsk (the South- Eastern regions) where a protracted conflict broke out? Are they not part of the resolution to the Ukraine crisis? But before any party decides on how to resolve the Ukrainian crisis, it is crucial to understand what needs to be resolved.

 What needs to be Resolved?

First, the negotiating status. Formal peace talks began with the Minsk-I ceasefire in September 2014 but Kyiv refused to engage with rebels as negotiation partners, even while Kyiv’s negotiators had no official status, proceeding to brand rebels as ‘terrorists’ (Matveeva, 2018, p. 260). For as long as the insurgents are not considered cohorts in negotiating a peace deal and power sharing arrangements, the Ukraine crisis will not resolve. Second, the political fate of the insurgent territory. At the crisis’s outset, Donbas seemed to concord with Russia about the federalization idea (Davies, 2016, p. 737), but as the conflict progressed, rebels’ aspirations were geared either towards complete independence or irredentism with Russia – the former, Ukraine would never give, and the latter, Russia did not want. The ‘Special Status’ option running into a political impasse coupled with Ukrainian civil activist efforts against Minsk agreements meant that the crisis was not ripe for peace from Kyiv’s side. On the split side, the Donbas rebels’ dissatisfaction with Moscow and Kyiv for neglecting rebel wishes also meant that the crisis was not ready to be resolved from their side either. All parties were dissatisfied with the outcomes. It is not wrong therefore to say that Ukrainian nationalism and monist identity approach was only becoming stronger with rebels’ resistance to Kyiv’s biddings. Thus, for as long as the rebels are not awarded some sort of autonomy or freedom to live their “Russianness,” the crisis will not be resolved. At the same time, for as long as the rebels are firm on irredentist motives instead of attributing some form of loyalty to Kyiv, the SE-Ukraine crisis will prolong and cannot be resolved. It goes without saying that the resolution needs to be political, not military. As with any conflict, ceasefires are only temporary arrangements for until a greater political plan is formed. As the many (failed) ceasefire attempts indicate, Ukraine needs to seriously determine a political solution for the conflict to truly stop.

Ukraine Crisis and European Security

No matter how the Ukraine crisis is resolved, some things from the crisis serve as important notes for European security. First, the Donbas conflict is a strong reminder that for regional stability and order, it is necessary to devote attention to grassroots rebellions instead of single-mindedly fantasizing over the “all-Putin” narrative. Crimea was the tip of the iceberg; it is possible that such dormant grassroots rebellions could foment and induce a regional domino effect throwing the fragile balance off the continent. Second, it is unreasonable to take insurgent groups’ military organization and political aspirations for granted. Within Ukraine, rebels have showed the skill and experience needed to spontaneously mobilize and acquire modern warfare methods, which means, that such revolutions can very much happen despite state defense methods. Was (is) Ukraine prepared for this? Are Kyiv’s European friends prepared for this? Furthermore, when grievances are addressed in the form of violent conflict, a pro-war culture unites people with similar ideologies. How can Europe stop European fighters from fighting in Donbas? The moment that a cultural war becomes war-culture is indeed tricky – so Europe needs to take into account the strength of identities, symbols, and beliefs, and how that can affect the fragile security in the region, instead of brewing the ‘Russia-orchestrates-all’ beverage. Lastly, with whatever political resolution that Ukraine comes up with, European security and stability is only possible with Russia’s cooperation. Antagonizing Russia will not help integrate pro-Russian factions within pro-West states like Ukraine. This would mean not only cooperating with Russia for further regional stability, but also not isolating it. Russia’s past attempts of halting the Novorossiya project in Donbas, postponing elections in rebel territories, enthusiasm for peace prospects including suggesting UN peacekeeping troops cannot be simply rewarded with more economic sanctions. That defeats good faith from Russia. This causes Russia to turn away from cooperation with the EU, and with it, induce its pro-Russian supporters (scattered all over the FSU) to imitate the same.

Loading...


Ukraine Crisis and Russian Security

If a political-military resolution is found to end the Ukraine crisis, it has some implications on Russian security too. First, Russia needs to be prepared for calls to the ‘Russian World.’ A population who was driven to go to war because they had faith Russia would repeat Crimea means that such dormant attitudes maybe present within other FSU populations. Matveeva (2018, 286) states that “Russia does not have a universalist approach to regional conflicts,” and Donbas is a clear example of that. Whatever the resolution is agreed upon for Ukraine, a big question that looms over Russian security is about how it would take care of regional military confrontations. Russia uses a bilateral and multilateral approach in order to bind states into a regional order, but the aspect about a military confrontation remains unanswered (Slobodchikoff 2014). Whether we look at CIS or some other multilateral organization, there needs to be some forum which either addresses collective security operations (actual military confrontations) or allows Russia to intervene as necessary. The Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) has been a good tool for Russia in integrating Eurasia against external threats (Hansen 2013), but has Russia seriously considered civil and transnational (internal) conflicts which can turn into full-blown civil wars if allowed? Even if Russia finds it pointless to entertain civil skirmishes like the one in Donbas, how can it ignore the fundamental drive – Novorossiya– which served as the rebels’ motivational catalyst? All this indicates that Russian security is invariably a matter of regional stability, very much taking into account Ukraine. So, it is only in Russian security interests to mollify such uprisings using support from mainland governments and/or a multilateral security architecture, thereby standardizing its approach to such regional hostilities. Unless, of course, it is Russia’s wish to stay mysterious with its security approach. If that be so, such an approach does not bode well for regional security. Secondly, for any sort of crisis resolution to sustain, Russia will have to understand Kyiv’s perspective. Although it has to rush to aid its Russian World when she summons her, Moscow cannot overplay this cultural dimension so much as to explicitly challenge the West and thereby feed into the Western normative discourse. Ukraine will be more than unwilling to make any more concessions past Crimea, so Donbas’s resolution (when it happens), would require sacrifices on both fronts and acknowledgment of bitter history.

Of course rebels in Donbas or Kyiv, the governments in Moscow and Kyiv, as also the wider continents of Europe and America would appreciate a true peace, but ‘peace’ cannot be viewed as an absolute dichotomy: either my way or the highway. A ceasefire may bring about a transient military resolution, but without a political one unanimously agreed by involved parties, it is unlikely that the Ukrainian crisis will end in spirit.

In order to avoid such future conflicts, both Russia and Europe must understand how overlooked conflicts such as those in Donbas have security implications for both of them. For Russia, it means acknowledging the dormant (but very potent) society within the Russian World, as also Russia’s obligation as leader of that world – and while doing all of this, maintaining a delicate balance between itself and the West. For Europe it means acknowledging indigenous uprisings, giving due value to cultural enthusiasm uncontaminated by political conspiracies that feed in the all-Putin perspective, and faithfully cooperating with Moscow to attain regional stability.

So as we see, there is much theoretical resolution to the Ukraine crisis and how that will affect Russian and European securities, but practically, one has to wait to see. As Matveeva (2018,298) writes, “we can only hope humanity survived in those who went through it,” to which it would do well to add: I hope some foresight and rationality is present in those who are to resolve it.

Tanvi Chauhan
Global studies scholar from the US-based Troy University. âShe is specialist on the MENA and Eurasia politico-military and security theaters.

 Urmărește știrile Timpul.md pe Telegram
loading...
Loading...
blog comments powered by Disqus

Din aceeaşi secţiune

Cele mai noi ştiri de azi

News 24 February 2020, at: 11:58

Viktor Gusan, owner of the largest business in Moldova’s breakaway region of Transdniester, has Ukrainian citizenship as well as land and property ownership in the Kyiv and Odesa regions of Ukraine, an investigative journalism group reported over the weekend.

( ) Read all

News 24 February 2020, ora: 10:37

Italy loath to suspend Schengen despite coronavirus cases soar

Italy loath to suspend Schengen despite coronavirus cases soar

With the number of cases topping 150, Italy is facing the worst coronavirus outbreak outside Asia. Entire towns in the Northern part of the country were locked down, while schools were closed and public events, such as the iconic Venice Carnival, were cancelled.

( ) Read all

News 23 February 2020, ora: 12:32

Coronavirus cases in Italy rise to more than 100

Coronavirus cases in Italy rise to more than 100

Hospital personnel in Codogno, Italy, carry new beds inside the hospital on Friday, February 21. The hospital is hosting some people who have been diagnosed with the novel coronavirus.

( ) Read all

News 23 February 2020, ora: 12:22

Daredevil 'Mad Mike' Hughes dies while attempting to launch a homemade rocket / VIDEO

Daredevil 'Mad Mike' Hughes dies while attempting to launch a homemade rocket / VIDEO

Daredevil "Mad Mike" Hughes died during an attempt to launch his homemade rocket Saturday. "Our thoughts and prayers go out to Mike Hughes' family and friends during this difficult time. It was always his dream to do this launch, and Science Channel was there to chronicle his...

( ) Read all

News 22 February 2020, ora: 18:22

The Washington Post: Bernie Sanders briefed by U.S. officials that Russia is trying to help his presidential campaign

The Washington Post: Bernie Sanders briefed by U.S. officials that Russia is trying to help his presidential campaign

 U.S. officials have told Sen. Bernie Sanders that Russia is attempting to help his presidential campaign as part of an effort to interfere with the Democratic contest, according to people familiar with the matter.

( ) Read all

News 20 February 2020, at: 22:49

Russia's Constitutional Court becomes accomplice in international crime by legitimizing Crimea annexation – Lithuanian expert

Russia's Constitutional Court becomes accomplice in international crime by legitimizing Crimea annexation – Lithuanian expert

 President of Lithuania's Constitutional Court Dainius Zalimas says Russia's Constitutional Court became an accomplice in an international crime and aggression against Ukraine when it legitimized the accession of occupied Crimea to Russia.

( ) Read all

News 20 February 2020, at: 11:07

 Dagmar Turner wasn't just showing off when she played the violin during her brain surgery at King's College Hospital in London. Surgeons asked the 53-year-old to play her instrument to ensure that the professional violinist's musical abilities were not damaged during a tumor removal....

( ) Read all

News 19 February 2020, at: 17:16

Brussels should speak to Moldova directly rather rely on inaccurate information from European ambassadors in Chisinau.

( ) Read all

News 14 February 2020, at: 16:34

For the first time in Switzerland, a restaurant catering specifically to nudists will open its doors at the end of February. We reveal all. According to the newspaper Schweiz am Wochenende, the eatery, called "Edelweiss Basel - Nudisten Lounge", will open at Rebgasse 39, in the...

( ) Read all

News 6 February 2020, ora: 21:07

​​President Iohannis designates Liberal leader Orban for prime minister again

​​President Iohannis designates Liberal leader Orban for prime minister again

Romanian President Klaus Iohannis on Thursday designated Liberal (PNL) leader Ludovic Orban to lead a new government again, a day after Orban's government lost a censure motion in the Parliament.

( ) Read all

News 5 February 2020, ora: 22:41

Is Putin preparing a new Ukraine strategy?

Is Putin preparing a new Ukraine strategy?

 Many of the personnel changes announced recently by Russian President Vladimir Putin appear to be of little significance. However, there are indications that a major policy change towards Ukraine may be underway following reports that Putin has replaced his chief troublemaker Vladislav...

( ) Read all

News 4 February 2020, ora: 22:16

The Guardian Outspoken Chechen blogger found murdered in Lille

Outspoken Chechen blogger found murdered in Lille

  Imran Aliev, who had criticised Chechnya’s leader, was stabbed repeatedly in a hotel room

( ) Read all

News 3 February 2020, ora: 10:14

The Guardian Brexit, the most pointless, masochistic ambition in our country's history, is done

Brexit, the most pointless, masochistic ambition in our country's history, is done

 It’s done. A triumph of dogged negotiation by May then, briefly, Johnson, has fulfilled the most pointless, masochistic ambition ever dreamed of in the history of these islands. The rest of the world, presidents Putin and Trump excepted, have watched on in astonishment and dismay. A...

( ) Read all

News 2 February 2020, ora: 20:59

Cinema of Hidden Histories: Leontina Vatamanu’s Siberia in the Bones (2019)

Cinema of Hidden Histories: Leontina Vatamanu’s Siberia in the Bones (2019)

 Moldova has a fascinating recent history, and Leontina Vatamanu is perhaps its most articulate cinematic chronicler. Poke through her films, and you’ll realize that her cinema is one of hidden histories: whether it’s exploring one of Moldova’s most famous modern poets and...

( ) Read all

News 1 February 2020, ora: 20:22

Associated Press Pompeo in Belarus to push better ties, counter Russia, China

Pompeo in Belarus to push better ties, counter Russia, China

 MINSK, Belarus (AP) — U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is in Belarus seeking to improve ties with the former Soviet republic as its relations with Russia become further strained.

( ) Read all

News 31 January 2020, at: 21:07

Balkaninsight Moldova faces ‘existential’ population crisis

Moldova faces ‘existential’ population crisis

 From the Black Sea to the Adriatic, the issue of falling population numbers is a drama. In Moldova, it is a trauma. Since 1989, its population has shrunk by almost a third and in 15 years it may be only just over half of what it was back then.

( ) Read all

News 31 January 2020, ora: 07:25

Moldova warned to stop calling Romanian Moldovan

Moldova warned to stop calling Romanian Moldovan

Moldova has been warned to stop referring to its language as Moldovan - and call it Romanian instead.

( ) Read all

News 29 January 2020, at: 20:52

Foreign Policy How China’s Coronavirus Is Spreading—and How to Stop It

How China’s Coronavirus Is Spreading—and How to Stop It

Until the 21st century, the worst a coronavirus, a large family of viruses capable of infecting humans and animals, could do to humans was to deliver the common cold—annoying but hardly sinister. But three times so far in the 21st century, novel coronaviruses have emerged that could...

( ) Read all

News 24 January 2020, ora: 23:17

The Guardian Soros gives $1bn to fund universities 'and stop drift towards authoritarianism'

Soros gives $1bn to fund universities 'and stop drift towards authoritarianism'

 Philanthropist unveils plan for global network of institutions at Davos and attacks Trump as ‘ultimate narcissist’

( ) Read all

News 23 January 2020, at: 15:57

Putin's latest obsession: Rewriting World War II

Putin's latest obsession: Rewriting World War II

The 75th anniversary of the end of World War II was the only forthcoming event Russian President Vladimir Putin mentioned in his New Year’s address to the nation. Creating an alternative to the dominant Western narrative about that war is key to Putin’s way of securing Russia’s...

( ) Read all

News 23 January 2020, ora: 15:54

Chinese pneumonia outbreak (2019-nCoV): An emerging threat to global public health?

Chinese pneumonia outbreak (2019-nCoV): An emerging threat to global public health?

 “People’s live and health should be given top priority and the spread of the outbreak should be resolutely curbed”. – President Xi Jinping

( ) Read all

News 23 January 2020, at: 07:27

Trains and flights out of the central Chinese city have been canceled as the toll from a new coronavirus grows. The Chinese city of Wuhan, the seventh largest in the country with approximately 11 million people, will be under a partial quarantine from 10 a.m. Chinese time Thursday, according...

( ) Read all

News 22 January 2020, ora: 20:18

Foreign Policy Vladimir Putin Wants to Rewrite the History of World War II

Vladimir Putin Wants to Rewrite the History of World War II

 The Russian president’s amateur history lessons are outraging neighboring countries. While he is right to criticize a recent EU Parliament resolution, his historical revisionism doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

( ) Read all

News 22 January 2020, ora: 12:30

Statement by Council of Europe Secretary General Marija Pejčinović Burić on judicial reform in the Republic of Moldova

Statement by Council of Europe Secretary General Marija Pejčinović Burić on judicial reform in the Republic of Moldova

In December 2019, I met with the Prime Minister of the Republic of Moldova, Ion Chicu. We agreed that Council of Europe experts would visit Chisinau with a view to offering our assistance towards reforms needed to create an independent, accountable, efficient and professional judiciary for the...

( ) Read all

News 22 January 2020, ora: 10:16

Moldova’s president’s persecution of the prosecutor

Moldova’s president’s persecution of the prosecutor

On Friday, January 10, Viorel Morari, Moldova’s Anti-Corruption Prosecutor, was detained. Initially held for 72 hours, Morari’s arrest was extended on January 13 for a further 30 days. A number of international outlets reported Mr. Morari’s circumstances, due to the political...

( ) Read all

News 20 January 2020, ora: 18:52

Ambassador Thomas Mayr-Harting, OSCE Special Representative for the Transdniestrian Settlement Process, to visit the Republic of Moldova from 21 to 23 January

Ambassador Thomas Mayr-Harting, OSCE Special Representative for the Transdniestrian Settlement Process, to visit the Republic of Moldova from 21 to 23 January

During his visit from 21 to 23 January, the OSCE Special Representative for the Transdniestrian Settlement Process Ambassador Thomas Mayr-Harting will hold talks with high-level Moldovan officials and the political leadership in Tiraspol.

( ) Read all

News 20 January 2020, ora: 10:33

UK-US relations: Challenges ahead

UK-US relations: Challenges ahead

 The past few days have been witness, to some important statements made in the context of the Joint Comprehensive Program for Action (JCPOA) — also referred to as the Iran Nuclear deal. US allies, including the UK and some EU member states do not seem to be in agreement with the US...

( ) Read all
Current tier / breakpoint: xs sm md lg xl (= visible only on this breakpoint)

.hidden-xs-down .hidden-sm-down .hidden-md-down .hidden-lg-down

.hidden-xs-up .hidden-sm-up .hidden-md-up .hidden-lg-up .hidden-xl

.hidden-xs (only) .hidden-sm (only) .hidden-md (only) .hidden-lg (only) .hidden-xl (only)